Steven 'Prozak' Shippy | ... | Self - Host, Paranormal Investigator and Documentary Filmmaker (as Steven T. Shippy) | |
Cindy Kaza | ... | Self - Host, Psychic Medium | |
Michelle Fenski | ... | Self - Paranormal Investigator | |
Dave Bignell | ... | Self - Plainfield Local | |
Tom Dyar | ... | Self - Local Resident | |
Lori McCloud | ... | Self - Plainfield Historian | |
Andy Thundercloud | ... | Self - Ho-Chunk Tribe Elder | |
Ed Gein | ... | Self (archive footage) | |
Tim Perez-Ross | ... | Ed Gein (as Tim Ross) | |
Kera O'Bryon | ... | Augusta Gein | |
Alex Stavrevski | ... | Young Ed Gein | |
Rest of cast listed alphabetically: | |||
Jay Gates | ... | Sheriff Art Schley (uncredited) | |
Janae Palmer | ... | Sarah May (uncredited) | |
Matthew Thompson | ... | Male Skin-Walker (uncredited) | |
Sawyer Williams | ... | Denny Layton (uncredited) |